AN IDEA AND THOUGHT ABOUT HUMANISM OF DIFFERENT WORLD FAMOUS PERSONALITIES
(A CRITICAL AND COMPARATIVE STUDY)
BY
Dr. Purna Chandra Bishayee
(Jyotish Shastri, Jyotish Siddhantra Shastri)
E-mail: pcbishayee@gmail.com
purnachandrabishayee@gmail.com
Mobile: 08902727101
Address: 259, Dr. B. C. Roy Sarani, Bara Battala,New Barrakpur, Qu.No. 3B, Kolkata-700131
JYOTISH NEEKETAN, RENJURA, MIDNAPUR, 721443
According to ‘History’ the ideology of great man is continuing generation by generation through men. The great men have represented themselves through the history of men. This thought was symbolized as ‘Maha-Manab’ by Nobel awarded Rabindranath Tagore.
In the Gita it has been expressed that ‘ Dharma Sansthapthanathya Sambhabhami Jujey Jujey’ The violation of human rights-‘humanism’ has been observed from the very age old time, when man became civilize. During the time of ‘Treta’ Ramchandra, the great king of Ayodhya (who is now a days respect by the people) violated the humanism during the time of were between Bali and Sugriv . Next, in the ‘Dapara’, Lord Krishna who is also respected now a days, also violated the basic norms of humanism at the battlefield during the time ware of Mahabharata. The violation of humanism observed maximum during ‘Kali Jugha’, particularly during 17th, 18th, 19th and 20th century. In 19th century, the doctrine of humanism of French philosopher Auguste Comte was very popular throughout the world. In place of God, he places humanism. *1 The view about humanism by Comte is not point of our discussion. Our viewpoint is to discuss about the humanism of some great men (called ‘Maha-Manab’) and some world famous personality through their birth charts (horoscope) in light of Astrology. Although the people respect some, yet, all of them never are honored as a real humanist in true sense. Among them a few can be recognized as a humanist. Now the question raised why they are not humanist? What are the minimum criteria for a person that he may be recognized as a humanist? Now the fist questions arise - What is humanism?
The word ‘Humanism’ comes from ‘Latin’ world ‘Humanitas’, which means to search the perfection of one self. It always inspires to raise oneself, s strength.
About humanism S. Radhakrishnan expressed his views that “God is Supreme revolutionary. He is the master builder and so we are the servants of God, we must work for truth, for the truth which means the establishment of right relationships between man and man, community and community nation and nation.”*2
Human relationships are the mainspring of spiritual life. Man worships his God in all the true objects of man’s worship. Through love, man can understand others and realize the supreme in the heart of him.
Humanism related with the religion of man. About the Religion of Man - Prabhat Kumar Mukharjee express as his views in that way “We have heard Hindu’s religion, Muslim’s religion, Christian’s religion… … Generally, we define the ‘man’ in terms of cast or nationality - Brahman, Vaishya, Sudra – or blacksmith, potter, weaver and we know the nationality - as English, Russian, Japanese, Chinese, Generally people are habituated to this culture. Sometimes some great man, sages have come within us and hit on our such ignorance and have told about the universal man, who do not belong to any caste.”*3
The word ‘Religion’ comes from the Latin word ‘Religo’. It comes from religare (re-ligare = to bind back), i.e. who tightly bind together that is religion. In English ‘ligate’ means ‘tie up’. In Sanskrit ‘Dharma’ come from the world ‘Dhri’ and means, which grasp the whole.
The science does not mean the science of English, science of French, science of India; science is the science wherever it may be. In this way Dharma (religion) means man’s dharma or man’s religion. It never be the separate religion. If any special religion, which hits the man’s religion then it, must be clear that he is hindering the truth the untruth is functioning in intrigue, which is evil, and this is death. The religion of modern age is the ‘Religion of Man’, which called ‘Humanism’. *4
According to S. Radhakrishnan, “ Philosophy fails of its purpose and is unfaithful to its ideal if it assumes that particular religious beliefs should be accepted.” *4
Generally we called the religion as ‘Dharma’. ‘Dharma’ means perception’ or ‘perceptual realisation’. In other words, we can define it as ‘immediate awareness’ or ‘to see God face to face’. In West, philosophy is dependent on intellectual knowledge. But in East particularly in India, it is intuitive knowledge. This intuitive knowledge is one kind of modification of the intellectual knowledge.
Man’s philosophy is dependent upon his thinking of life and realization of ‘Universal Truth’. The truth is beauty and beauty is truth. Man is the worshiper of such truth. This truth has a universal picture. Therefore, ‘Inner Universal Truth’ is the man’s religion. Humanism is the religion of every man. Therefore, as a subject ‘Religioin of Man’ and ‘Humanism’ is more or less same, because religion of man is not a specific religion but it is based on humanism.
About the religion and humanism the great humanist Rebindranath Tagore express his views by given a nice example-“ Animal’s nature e.g., its livelihood is its religion. But in case of human beings, livelihood can never be the only his nature, humanity is his main characteristic. So ‘ Inner Universal Truth’ is man’s religion.”*5
Humanism is clearly revealed universality and sense of identify with all men, and revolt against all types of tyranny and injustice. Life is its fullness, in its exaltation of the human reason and the luminous quality of his faith and above all, in respect for the human personality is heeding towards completion.
Religion should never be based upon the Koran or the Puran, the Vedas or the Upanishad, the Bible or the Tripitaka, Granthasab or Gita, etc, it is on humanism. Religion of any person should be based on the man’s religion, not at the outside orbit of man. So religion should be centralizes on humanism and it must be root of man’s life. There are no higher religion than that of sympathy for all that lives. Love is the foundation of all religions.
Every person possesses a special something, which he calls ‘his religion’. A man’s religion does not consist of blind beliefs that obstruct our comprehension; rather, it is as man’s innermost truth, a creative force, a life-sense, greater than his materials sense.
Every man possesses a religious though. The main nature of the religion is non-material approach. Love, kindness, ahimsa all positive characteristics consist in the religion. Practically, religion is a universal power, which is related with finite and infinite, matter and consciousness. It is one kind of manifestation of soul, which is birth less, deathless and universal. There is no binding in the religion of man and humanism. Religion relates finite soul with the infinite soul and it washes out all the evils of main’s heart. That’s why it makes a man a ‘God man’.
Beauty and truth are related with religion and humanism. If we do not love the truth, then it is not possible for us to adopt it. We cannot bind the truth with any artificial binding. Ideal life is related with truthfulness and ‘Dharma’ is not beyond these characteristics. The idea of religion is not the same as like the traditional idea that possess by the common people. Human nature is the human religion. The real meaning of religion is the ‘nature’ or ‘characteristic’ of a thing. For example, the nature of fire is its heat and power of burning, the nature of water is to wet. In the same way, the nature of good religion is to do well to others and that of a bad religion is to do harm to others. The nature of selfishness is to express one’s love centering round oneself only, whereas the nature of benevolence is to express love for others.
About the humanism the famous Bengali poet Chandidas express his views in this way:
‘Sunoho Manush Bhai
Sabar Uporey Masush Satya
Tahar Uporey Nai.’
The theory of humanism is observed in every religion but some times the application on the society or the society or upon the ‘Human-Beings’ by powerful persons in their own way, which they demand the religion of that cast, society etc. But actually this is not the true religion this may be said as dogma. Rabindranath expresses his view is that way-‘…………The felling of man is not equal everywhere and in some where it is prevent and for that all man are till not recognized as a real man’. The Vaishnava and Baul, Sufi and Fakir, Sant strictly followed the rules of humanism. Of them there is no any sadhana except Baul in the human society in our world who strictly followed, obey and respect the humanism, and for that there is no conflict and clashed between the Baul and other people of different religions although there is a conflict and clashed between and among the other religions.
The inhumanity within a man arise when he thinks in his mind and draws a difference between worshiper and himself, and man and God, and ultimately man and man. Rabindranath express his views in the Manusher Dharma is this way-“A worshipper of God is no better than a beast if he worships such God whose entity is quite different from the entity of the worshipper; because such imagination of God leads the worshipper to get himself chained by narrow outlook of life. His own created God drive him out from his own entity.’’*6
In their songs, the Baul expresses their realization of God in the same way as sages in the ‘Upanishds’ did; Rabindranath expressed his cogitation in his Hibbert Lecture, ‘The Religion of Man’. In the typed manuscript of ‘The Religion of Man’, a few lines of the Baul song (in Bengali) were jotted down by his own handwriting where the main theory of humanism is hidden.
যেমন ভাবন তেমনি ভূবন
ভাবে ভবে মাখা মাখি ।
মানুষ নইলে কোথায় দাঁড়ায়,
অচেতনে সবই হারায়,
যখন মিলবে সাড়া তোর সে সাড়ায়,
বুঝবি তখন পাকাপাকি ।
“The world is as it is in our thought, the thought and existence are commingled. Everything would be lost in unconsciousness if may ware naught, and when response come to your own call you know the meaning of reality.”*7
The theory of humanism of Baul is also somewhat analogy with the philosophy, religion and humanism of Jainism.
In the Jain religion and philosophy, it is said that different persons old the views of the ‘Absolute Truth Theory’, from different aspects, but the deduction of each individual’s view carries some sort of truth. This very view of the philosophy of Jain religion is found to be in harmony with that of great humanist Rabindranath, where he states that he also does not view God as separate entity from that of him. “The lover seeks his own other self in his beloved.”* 8. Tagore carries this truth in his various writings. These are the components of identify in the philosophy, religion and humanism of Rabindranath. The difficulty lies in these circumstances, so it is how to present these spiritual cogitation of Tagore methodically.
By developing such theory day after day, year after year, how, why and when it has been stopped - a short answer of this question can be found from the jest of the close door discussions conference between the great humanist famous Scientist Albert Einstein and Noble Poet Rabindranath Tagore just after the Hibbert Lecture, which is as follows:
Tagore said, ‘When our universe is in harmony with man, the eternal, we know it as truth we fell it as beauty.’
Einstein answered ‘This is a purely human concepts of the universe.’
Rabindranath added in, ‘There can be no other conception. This world is a human world, the scientific fiew of it is also that of the scientific man.’
‘…………… if there be some truth which has no sensuous or relation to the human mind it will ever remain as nothing so long as we remain as human beings.’
A person in the world where he belongs to any cast and/or creed may be classified into two groups whether he is human or inhuman. Every man has it’s own religion. Such as Rabindranath has ‘Poet religion’, Ramkrishna has ‘Deb/Purahit religion’, Newton, Einstein have ‘Scientist religion’, Mussolini and Hitler have ‘Worrior religion, Chaitanya has ‘Vedantic religion’, Lord Krishna has ‘Political religion’. But they must be either human or inhuman in their character. So either humanity or inhumanity must be looked if we go through their horoscope.
The role of man in the society is different; he some times slows humanity and some times inhumanity in his short span in his life. For example, the great Empire Ashok in his life, at the early period he was a most inhuman person, but after the Kalinga War humanity developed in his mind and he become a great man. Opposite case also been seen in the so many persons mainly engaged in the different works particularly like politics and power. That also depends upon the dasha bhukti of the native. But as a whole when we go through the birth chart at a glance we can say that whether a person is human or inhuman.
“To killed the enemy is the religion of life, by overcoming this, man says, ‘to forgive the enemy’, which is unexpected. This is detrimental for the religion of life but enlistment of humanism.”*9
REFERENCE:
*1. a) August Comte – Positive Polity, Vol.II.
b) August Comte – Religion or Humanity.
c) August Comte- General views of Positivism.
d) August Comte- The Positive Philosophy.
*2. Radhakrishnan,S; East and West Religion, P-140.
*3. Mukharjee, Prabhat Kumar; Ravindra Jivani, Vol.3, P-501.
*4. Radhakrishnan, S. The Reign of Religion in Contemporary Philosophy, P-7
*5. Tagore, R.N.; Atmaparichay, Rabindra Rachanabali, (Visva Bharati), Vol. 14, P-152.
*6. Tagore, R.N.; Manusher Dharma, Rabindra Rachanabali, (Visva Bharti ),Vol.10, P-642.
*7. Tagore, R.N.; Typed Manuscript of The Religion of Man, P-18.
*8. Tagore, R.N.; Sadhana, P-86.
*9. Tagore, R.N.; Manusher Dharma, Rabindr Rachanbali (Visva Bharti), Vol.10,
P-642.
SOME BOUL SONGS UPON HUMANISM
HUMANISM OF SOME WORLD FAMOUS PERSONALITY
(A CRITICAL STUDY AND DISCUSSION FROM SOME HOROSCOPE IN LIGHT OF ASTROLOGY).
We will discuss the horoscope of some renowned world famous personalities and critically studies regarding their humanity.
CASE NO.- 01
Our dharmo shastra teaches us that during the time war, who is not in chariot and who is on contact with the earth, the opposite charioteer who is in the battlefield will never through his weapons to kill his opponent party or an opposer. But this was not happened in case of ware of Mahabharata where Lord Krishna advised, irritate and aggravate, insist Arjuna to thrown his weapons to killed Karna, when chariot of Karna was failed in the mud, and he was not in chariot and became perplexity and aghast and was trying to remove the wheel of chariot from the muddy soil. At that time Arjuna with the advice of Lord Krishna thrown his arms and weapons to killed Karna and Karna lost his life.
In our shastra it is advice to all of us that not to kill who are not participate in the war, which is in sorrow. Lord Krishna irritates Arjuna to killed Mahatma Vishma who left his arms in the battlefield. Not only that he was also adviced to killed Dronacharya, who was in sorrow hearing the news that his son Aswathama died in the battle field as decleared by Judhistir, that ‘Aswathama Hata Iti Gaja’ with the advice of Lord Krishna. Therefore, from our civic and commonsense we can never say that Lord Krishna follows the rules of humanism. And we put Lord Krishna in the group of inhuman persons. Now question arise why Lord Krishna did such? If we go through the horoscope we will observed that Rahu who is the most non-religious planet present in the 5th house aspect the 9th houses, the house of dharma (religion). Mars the 7th and 12th Lord present in the 9th house and aspect by 8th Lord Jupiter. In case of Vrisha (Taurus) langna Mars is the malefic planet and marak, and Mars is a warrior planet. Again, Jupiter as a malefic and marak planet aspect the 9th house is not good. Therefore, native participated in the war for dharma and himself not been a humanist . The 9th Lord who is the responsible for dharma is in exaltation is good but in 6th house is also bad. 6th house is the house of enemy injury and aspect by malefic, ill-boding, non-religious Rahu through it’s 12th aspect. The cruel nature of the native was developed due to the aspect of malefic Rahu upon ascendant and on mind karka planet Moon, who is also in the Lagna. Rahu is also aspect on the Lagna Lord, and the 9th and 10th lord (Karmapati) Saturn. Again, Rahu is also with intellect karka planet Merecuty, Mercury the 5th lord responsible for intuition (future vision). Again, Rahu aspect on Mars the worrier planet. Sun is aspect by cruel planet Mars. The presence of Saturn in the 6th house insist native to be cruel (in nature), diplomat and adapt in affectedness.
So, how such a person become a humanist whose 9th lord is affected by malefic planet Rahu and and 9th house is expected by the 8th in lord and 12th lord? Therefore, although Krishna now a day may be respected and popular, but he was never be a humanist because he was cruel in nature and violated all norms of humanism during the time of war of Mahabharata.
CASE NO. 02
In our dharma shastra it is advice us not to throw your arms and weapons to killed other who is in the battlefield not with you but with others.
In the Treta Yuga, Lord Ramchandra who was the 3rd person in the war between the Bali and his younger brother Sugriv , throw his arms to killed Bali which is not only the violation of the rules of war but also against the dharmashastra and humanism. So it indicates the inhumanity of Lord Ramchandra. What Ramchandra did was only for his wife Sita who was under Ravana at Lanka during that time. This type of work proves not only the selfishness of Ramchandra but also express the inhumanity of him.
If we go through the horoscope of Lord Ram, it can seen that although the horoscope is no doubt a good horoscope, yet, there is some lacuna which can never be deny. The lagna and lagna lord is affected by malefic planet 8th lord Saturn. The 7th aspect of Mars on lagna and lagna lord irritate the native and loss of religious mind and attitude, and native mind become war crime. The presence of Ketu, which is malefic planet present in the 9th house, is not good for a humanist, and native actually become irreligious minded of humanism. Astrologically actually native became an irreverent person in the eye of humanist. The aspect of Rahu in the 4th house (the house of social work the works for others) is not good. The aspect of Rahu upon 4th lord or Ketu with Venus is not good that when Venus which is also a representative of dharma along with poisonous planet Ketu hamper the religions character of the native and native became a irreverent person. The aspect of Saturn upon 9th lord Jupiter changes the character as irreligious. So, inhumanity found in the birth chart or Ramchandra.Again, he (Ram) also left his wife Sita and his younger brother Lakshmana those who accompany him with their sacrifice at his adverse time. Because his 3rd, 4th and 7th house represents the younger brother, 4th represents happiness and 7th represents wife. Jataka was unable to overcome the effect of such malefic planets.
“The spritual Astrology teaches us that the saints and the seers, the wise and the mystic can rule their stars, the ordinary people obey them” (astrology – X Royed, P-50). Jataka (Lord Ram) was unable to rule his stars, so we can’t say him as an extra ordinary person. He unable to overcome his ‘Dhira Karma’ and he became an inhuman in nature for some times. The great poet William Shakespear what he has written is absolutely true.
“ It is the stars the stars above us
Govern our conditions”.
CASE NO.- 03.
In the shastra it is advice to all that not to kill the person who is not in war, who is only seeing the war, people those who are not participate in the war, innocent people, person who is in fears, whose arms has broken, who is in bare condition, who is sleeping or taking rest. The so-called world leaders did not follow these norms in the present war particularly during the time of 2nd World War. And one of them was Hitler the number one inhuman person.
In the horoscope of Hitler the 9th Lord Mercury is present in the 7th house along with 8th lord Venus, maraca Mars (malefic planet of this lagna Tula), Sun, and aspect by malefic planet Jupiter. The karmapati Moon present in the 3rd house the house of braveness along with the malefic planet Jupiter, the 3rd lord (the braveness) and 6th lord (the enemy, hostility karaka planet) and poisonous planet Ketu. The ascendant is aspect by malefic planet. Sun, Mars, Rahu. Not only that Rahu who is most inhuman karaka planet and responsible for inhuman character of any person and ungodly planet among the all planets present in the house of 9th position, the house of dharma, guru, charity, intuition. Therefore, native never be a religious minded person and also never be a humanist. Actually native killed so many innocent people during the time of 2nd World War and he was the most inhuman person in the world. Jupiter along with Ketu and Rahu in 9th house and retrograde of lagna lord along with warrior planets Mars, Sun and aspect of Saturn upon it leads to jataka as a generalissimo, villain, depravity and corrupt, detestable, vile in nature.
CASE NO. –04
The following horoscope is the renound world famous generalissimo who was the villain in the Ist World War – Mussolini. In this horoscope the 9th lord Moon is in 7th house exaltation along with the cruel planet Mars and malefic retrograde planet Saturn. 5th lord Jupiter is in the 8th house aspect by malefic Rahu. 9th house is aspect by Saturn (with its 3rd aspect). Ascendant is aspect by malefic Rahu and cruel planet Mars, which given anger and cruelty to the native. The aspect of Rahu upon Jupiter given power to do herm against the people, Again 12th and 8th lords Venus and Mercury in 9th house along with 10th lord Karmapati Sun, and the aspect of Saturn upon them give adverse results about the work of religious matter. The ‘Kalsharpa Yoga’ is also observed in this horoscope. The 4th house, which is the house of social works, is also aspect by Rahu. Social work is one kind of religious work. Therefore, native never be religious minded, not only that his arrogance, cruelty and non-religious nature insist him to do harms against the Human Beings and he was become the most inhuman person.
‘Love is the religion of hero and violence is the religion of terrorist, coward, villain. The main recognition of the man is that he is a creator’. But neither the Hitler nor the Mussolini was never be a creator but they are destructor, and inhuman in nature. And for that they were violated all human rights and abuse their power to profane humankind and for that they killed many people and through their violence and the whole world became restless.
In this connection the last discussion between the great humanists Nobel awarded Rabindranath Tagore and Mussolini at Rome on evening dtd. 13.6.1926 before left Rome by Tagore is relevant. Tagore’s views, “Material, wealth and power cannot make a country immortal, she must contribute something which is great and which is for every body, and which does not merely glorify her own self”. Mussolini did not replied and keeps silent because it was known to him that ‘Idealists and humanists are always think and express such.’ He was neither idealist not the humanist, so the advice and sermon from Tagore was meaningless to him. Tagore express his view in they way “Man is his fullness is not powerful but perfect.” Perhaps it was known to him (Tagore) that Mussolini will not accept and followed his suggestions. Yet, he performed his duty because he believed in the ideology that ‘If the people be hard of hearing, yet, hymn of truth must be utter and narrate’.
People says ‘Nah Papey Patipapo Sath’- You should never commit sin or took revenge against him who is against you, in moral or religious offence to do harm’. But it can never be say that it is an advice of a mad and this is called humanism. The implement of such theory in the life is very difficult and depends upon the nature of the person, which can be measured from his horoscope.
Person followed and implemented this theory in his personal life is obviously and humanist. Such persons are Lord Goutam Buddha, Jesus Christ, Cahitanya, Ramkrishna, Rabindranath Tagore and others. The horoscopes of them are as follows:
From the above discussion it can be concluded that the following points are the essential factors found in the horoscope of a humanist or in humanist.
1) A person must be inhuman if Rahu is in the 9th house, because 9th house is the house of dharma or religion. A non-religious person is always inhuman in nature and Rahu is not regious planet.
2) For humanist lagna lord must be good aspect with 9th lord.
3) Presence of Moon must be either in lagna or in the 7th house or it must be good aspect with lagna.
4) 5th lord must either aspect lagna or Moon or lagna lord.
5) Lagna lord may be in exaltation.
6) Jupiter must be either aspect lagna or Moon or lagna lord.
7) No malefic planet either present or aspect 9th and 5th house. (Exception in special case may be found with proper reason) i.e. Ketu is not a malefic planet when present in 9th house.
8) The Raj yoga karaka planet must be in exalteted in the horoscope.
9) Lagna lord, 5th lord, 9th lord may be exaltated.
10) The native must be non-religious and inhuman in nature if any debilitation planet present in the 9th house or the 9th lord is either in the 6th, 8th or 12th house. The nature of native must be miser, selfish, non-religious and inhuman.
11) If the 9th lord be weak and any debilitation planet is in the 9th house and any malefic planet is in lagna and in the 5th house or is in the7th house. If Jupiter may be aspect with Rahu or in the same house the native may be inhuman in nature and he/she do any evil work and must be cruel in nature and never be kind hearted.
The humanism of a great man is no doubt a debatable matter. We have discussed it from our present situation and from our own outlook. Actually socio-economic conditions, situation and history during that time (Huga) when the native was passing his/her lifetime are now not clear to us. Again, the ‘Bargabal’ of the planets, ‘Sayanadi Dadas Bhaba or all planets and ‘Dasa-Antardasha’ of the native are also an important to came to any conclusion and decision. So, the humanity of such great persons is obviously a debatable subject.
A person started to make ready a new passage or narrow lane for walking. Then there is enough persons seen who try to develop the lane to road and converted to street. And there is no deficient of man for waling on the road. Only I have tried to express my approach to the thinkers and request all to developed this new topic from the view point of Jyotish Shastra. Hope, my humble approach will appreciated by the thinkers of this subject.
HOROSCOPE
Lord Krishna ( Case No - 01) : Vrisa- Lagna & Chandra; Karkata- Jupiter; Simha- Ravi; Kanya- Bubha & Rahu; Tula- Sukra & Sani; Makara-Mangala; Mina- Ketu.
Lord Ramchandra ( Case No – 02) : Karkata- Lagna, Chandra & Guru; Kanya- Rahu; Tula- Sani; Makar- Mangal; Mina – Sukra, Rabi & Ketu; Mesh- Budha,
Hitler (Case No - 03) : Tula – Lagna; Dhanu - Guru,Chandra & Ketu: Mesa-Rabi, Budha,Mangal & Sukra (R); Mithun-Rahu; Karkat- Sani
Musolini (Case No - 04) ; Vriscika-Lagna; Mesa-Ketu; Vrisa- Sani, Mangal &Chandra; Mithun- Guru;; Karkat- Rabi, Budh & Sukra; Tula- Rahu.
Lord Goutam Buddha : Karkat- Lagna; Tula-Chandra; Vriscik-Ketu; Mesa- Ravi, Mangal, Guru, Sukra & Sani; Vrisa- Budh; Mithun-Rahu.
Mahaprabhu Cahitanya : Simha- Lagna, Moon & Ketu; Vriscika-Sani; Dhanus- Guru; Makar- Mangal; Kumbha- Ravi & Rahu; Mina- Budha; Mesa- Sukra.
Ramkrishna Paramhansha : Kumbha- Lagna, Moon, Ravi & Budh; Min-Sukra; Vrisa-Ketu; Mithun- Guru; Tula- Sani; Vriscik-Rahu; Makar-Mangal.
Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore : Mina- Lagna[2/31 (25)] & Moon [20/42 (27)]; Mesa- Ravi [ 24/28 (2)], Budh[7/55(1) ] & Sukra [23/13(2)]; Mithun- Mangal [0/10 (5)] & Ketu [24/50 (7)]; Karkata- Guru [25/49 (9)]; Simha- Sani(BAKRI) [10/46 (10)]; Dhanus-Rahu [24/50 (20)]
Jesus Christ : Kanya- Lagna; Vrischik-Rahu & Sukra; Dhanus-Rabi & Budh; Kumbha- Mangal; Mina- Sani, Guru & Chandra; Vrisa- Ketu.
(A CRITICAL AND COMPARATIVE STUDY)
BY
Dr. Purna Chandra Bishayee
(Jyotish Shastri, Jyotish Siddhantra Shastri)
E-mail: pcbishayee@gmail.com
purnachandrabishayee@gmail.com
Mobile: 08902727101
Address: 259, Dr. B. C. Roy Sarani, Bara Battala,New Barrakpur, Qu.No. 3B, Kolkata-700131
JYOTISH NEEKETAN, RENJURA, MIDNAPUR, 721443
According to ‘History’ the ideology of great man is continuing generation by generation through men. The great men have represented themselves through the history of men. This thought was symbolized as ‘Maha-Manab’ by Nobel awarded Rabindranath Tagore.
In the Gita it has been expressed that ‘ Dharma Sansthapthanathya Sambhabhami Jujey Jujey’ The violation of human rights-‘humanism’ has been observed from the very age old time, when man became civilize. During the time of ‘Treta’ Ramchandra, the great king of Ayodhya (who is now a days respect by the people) violated the humanism during the time of were between Bali and Sugriv . Next, in the ‘Dapara’, Lord Krishna who is also respected now a days, also violated the basic norms of humanism at the battlefield during the time ware of Mahabharata. The violation of humanism observed maximum during ‘Kali Jugha’, particularly during 17th, 18th, 19th and 20th century. In 19th century, the doctrine of humanism of French philosopher Auguste Comte was very popular throughout the world. In place of God, he places humanism. *1 The view about humanism by Comte is not point of our discussion. Our viewpoint is to discuss about the humanism of some great men (called ‘Maha-Manab’) and some world famous personality through their birth charts (horoscope) in light of Astrology. Although the people respect some, yet, all of them never are honored as a real humanist in true sense. Among them a few can be recognized as a humanist. Now the question raised why they are not humanist? What are the minimum criteria for a person that he may be recognized as a humanist? Now the fist questions arise - What is humanism?
The word ‘Humanism’ comes from ‘Latin’ world ‘Humanitas’, which means to search the perfection of one self. It always inspires to raise oneself, s strength.
About humanism S. Radhakrishnan expressed his views that “God is Supreme revolutionary. He is the master builder and so we are the servants of God, we must work for truth, for the truth which means the establishment of right relationships between man and man, community and community nation and nation.”*2
Human relationships are the mainspring of spiritual life. Man worships his God in all the true objects of man’s worship. Through love, man can understand others and realize the supreme in the heart of him.
Humanism related with the religion of man. About the Religion of Man - Prabhat Kumar Mukharjee express as his views in that way “We have heard Hindu’s religion, Muslim’s religion, Christian’s religion… … Generally, we define the ‘man’ in terms of cast or nationality - Brahman, Vaishya, Sudra – or blacksmith, potter, weaver and we know the nationality - as English, Russian, Japanese, Chinese, Generally people are habituated to this culture. Sometimes some great man, sages have come within us and hit on our such ignorance and have told about the universal man, who do not belong to any caste.”*3
The word ‘Religion’ comes from the Latin word ‘Religo’. It comes from religare (re-ligare = to bind back), i.e. who tightly bind together that is religion. In English ‘ligate’ means ‘tie up’. In Sanskrit ‘Dharma’ come from the world ‘Dhri’ and means, which grasp the whole.
The science does not mean the science of English, science of French, science of India; science is the science wherever it may be. In this way Dharma (religion) means man’s dharma or man’s religion. It never be the separate religion. If any special religion, which hits the man’s religion then it, must be clear that he is hindering the truth the untruth is functioning in intrigue, which is evil, and this is death. The religion of modern age is the ‘Religion of Man’, which called ‘Humanism’. *4
According to S. Radhakrishnan, “ Philosophy fails of its purpose and is unfaithful to its ideal if it assumes that particular religious beliefs should be accepted.” *4
Generally we called the religion as ‘Dharma’. ‘Dharma’ means perception’ or ‘perceptual realisation’. In other words, we can define it as ‘immediate awareness’ or ‘to see God face to face’. In West, philosophy is dependent on intellectual knowledge. But in East particularly in India, it is intuitive knowledge. This intuitive knowledge is one kind of modification of the intellectual knowledge.
Man’s philosophy is dependent upon his thinking of life and realization of ‘Universal Truth’. The truth is beauty and beauty is truth. Man is the worshiper of such truth. This truth has a universal picture. Therefore, ‘Inner Universal Truth’ is the man’s religion. Humanism is the religion of every man. Therefore, as a subject ‘Religioin of Man’ and ‘Humanism’ is more or less same, because religion of man is not a specific religion but it is based on humanism.
About the religion and humanism the great humanist Rebindranath Tagore express his views by given a nice example-“ Animal’s nature e.g., its livelihood is its religion. But in case of human beings, livelihood can never be the only his nature, humanity is his main characteristic. So ‘ Inner Universal Truth’ is man’s religion.”*5
Humanism is clearly revealed universality and sense of identify with all men, and revolt against all types of tyranny and injustice. Life is its fullness, in its exaltation of the human reason and the luminous quality of his faith and above all, in respect for the human personality is heeding towards completion.
Religion should never be based upon the Koran or the Puran, the Vedas or the Upanishad, the Bible or the Tripitaka, Granthasab or Gita, etc, it is on humanism. Religion of any person should be based on the man’s religion, not at the outside orbit of man. So religion should be centralizes on humanism and it must be root of man’s life. There are no higher religion than that of sympathy for all that lives. Love is the foundation of all religions.
Every person possesses a special something, which he calls ‘his religion’. A man’s religion does not consist of blind beliefs that obstruct our comprehension; rather, it is as man’s innermost truth, a creative force, a life-sense, greater than his materials sense.
Every man possesses a religious though. The main nature of the religion is non-material approach. Love, kindness, ahimsa all positive characteristics consist in the religion. Practically, religion is a universal power, which is related with finite and infinite, matter and consciousness. It is one kind of manifestation of soul, which is birth less, deathless and universal. There is no binding in the religion of man and humanism. Religion relates finite soul with the infinite soul and it washes out all the evils of main’s heart. That’s why it makes a man a ‘God man’.
Beauty and truth are related with religion and humanism. If we do not love the truth, then it is not possible for us to adopt it. We cannot bind the truth with any artificial binding. Ideal life is related with truthfulness and ‘Dharma’ is not beyond these characteristics. The idea of religion is not the same as like the traditional idea that possess by the common people. Human nature is the human religion. The real meaning of religion is the ‘nature’ or ‘characteristic’ of a thing. For example, the nature of fire is its heat and power of burning, the nature of water is to wet. In the same way, the nature of good religion is to do well to others and that of a bad religion is to do harm to others. The nature of selfishness is to express one’s love centering round oneself only, whereas the nature of benevolence is to express love for others.
About the humanism the famous Bengali poet Chandidas express his views in this way:
‘Sunoho Manush Bhai
Sabar Uporey Masush Satya
Tahar Uporey Nai.’
The theory of humanism is observed in every religion but some times the application on the society or the society or upon the ‘Human-Beings’ by powerful persons in their own way, which they demand the religion of that cast, society etc. But actually this is not the true religion this may be said as dogma. Rabindranath expresses his view is that way-‘…………The felling of man is not equal everywhere and in some where it is prevent and for that all man are till not recognized as a real man’. The Vaishnava and Baul, Sufi and Fakir, Sant strictly followed the rules of humanism. Of them there is no any sadhana except Baul in the human society in our world who strictly followed, obey and respect the humanism, and for that there is no conflict and clashed between the Baul and other people of different religions although there is a conflict and clashed between and among the other religions.
The inhumanity within a man arise when he thinks in his mind and draws a difference between worshiper and himself, and man and God, and ultimately man and man. Rabindranath express his views in the Manusher Dharma is this way-“A worshipper of God is no better than a beast if he worships such God whose entity is quite different from the entity of the worshipper; because such imagination of God leads the worshipper to get himself chained by narrow outlook of life. His own created God drive him out from his own entity.’’*6
In their songs, the Baul expresses their realization of God in the same way as sages in the ‘Upanishds’ did; Rabindranath expressed his cogitation in his Hibbert Lecture, ‘The Religion of Man’. In the typed manuscript of ‘The Religion of Man’, a few lines of the Baul song (in Bengali) were jotted down by his own handwriting where the main theory of humanism is hidden.
যেমন ভাবন তেমনি ভূবন
ভাবে ভবে মাখা মাখি ।
মানুষ নইলে কোথায় দাঁড়ায়,
অচেতনে সবই হারায়,
যখন মিলবে সাড়া তোর সে সাড়ায়,
বুঝবি তখন পাকাপাকি ।
“The world is as it is in our thought, the thought and existence are commingled. Everything would be lost in unconsciousness if may ware naught, and when response come to your own call you know the meaning of reality.”*7
The theory of humanism of Baul is also somewhat analogy with the philosophy, religion and humanism of Jainism.
In the Jain religion and philosophy, it is said that different persons old the views of the ‘Absolute Truth Theory’, from different aspects, but the deduction of each individual’s view carries some sort of truth. This very view of the philosophy of Jain religion is found to be in harmony with that of great humanist Rabindranath, where he states that he also does not view God as separate entity from that of him. “The lover seeks his own other self in his beloved.”* 8. Tagore carries this truth in his various writings. These are the components of identify in the philosophy, religion and humanism of Rabindranath. The difficulty lies in these circumstances, so it is how to present these spiritual cogitation of Tagore methodically.
By developing such theory day after day, year after year, how, why and when it has been stopped - a short answer of this question can be found from the jest of the close door discussions conference between the great humanist famous Scientist Albert Einstein and Noble Poet Rabindranath Tagore just after the Hibbert Lecture, which is as follows:
Tagore said, ‘When our universe is in harmony with man, the eternal, we know it as truth we fell it as beauty.’
Einstein answered ‘This is a purely human concepts of the universe.’
Rabindranath added in, ‘There can be no other conception. This world is a human world, the scientific fiew of it is also that of the scientific man.’
‘…………… if there be some truth which has no sensuous or relation to the human mind it will ever remain as nothing so long as we remain as human beings.’
A person in the world where he belongs to any cast and/or creed may be classified into two groups whether he is human or inhuman. Every man has it’s own religion. Such as Rabindranath has ‘Poet religion’, Ramkrishna has ‘Deb/Purahit religion’, Newton, Einstein have ‘Scientist religion’, Mussolini and Hitler have ‘Worrior religion, Chaitanya has ‘Vedantic religion’, Lord Krishna has ‘Political religion’. But they must be either human or inhuman in their character. So either humanity or inhumanity must be looked if we go through their horoscope.
The role of man in the society is different; he some times slows humanity and some times inhumanity in his short span in his life. For example, the great Empire Ashok in his life, at the early period he was a most inhuman person, but after the Kalinga War humanity developed in his mind and he become a great man. Opposite case also been seen in the so many persons mainly engaged in the different works particularly like politics and power. That also depends upon the dasha bhukti of the native. But as a whole when we go through the birth chart at a glance we can say that whether a person is human or inhuman.
“To killed the enemy is the religion of life, by overcoming this, man says, ‘to forgive the enemy’, which is unexpected. This is detrimental for the religion of life but enlistment of humanism.”*9
REFERENCE:
*1. a) August Comte – Positive Polity, Vol.II.
b) August Comte – Religion or Humanity.
c) August Comte- General views of Positivism.
d) August Comte- The Positive Philosophy.
*2. Radhakrishnan,S; East and West Religion, P-140.
*3. Mukharjee, Prabhat Kumar; Ravindra Jivani, Vol.3, P-501.
*4. Radhakrishnan, S. The Reign of Religion in Contemporary Philosophy, P-7
*5. Tagore, R.N.; Atmaparichay, Rabindra Rachanabali, (Visva Bharati), Vol. 14, P-152.
*6. Tagore, R.N.; Manusher Dharma, Rabindra Rachanabali, (Visva Bharti ),Vol.10, P-642.
*7. Tagore, R.N.; Typed Manuscript of The Religion of Man, P-18.
*8. Tagore, R.N.; Sadhana, P-86.
*9. Tagore, R.N.; Manusher Dharma, Rabindr Rachanbali (Visva Bharti), Vol.10,
P-642.
SOME BOUL SONGS UPON HUMANISM
HUMANISM OF SOME WORLD FAMOUS PERSONALITY
(A CRITICAL STUDY AND DISCUSSION FROM SOME HOROSCOPE IN LIGHT OF ASTROLOGY).
We will discuss the horoscope of some renowned world famous personalities and critically studies regarding their humanity.
CASE NO.- 01
Our dharmo shastra teaches us that during the time war, who is not in chariot and who is on contact with the earth, the opposite charioteer who is in the battlefield will never through his weapons to kill his opponent party or an opposer. But this was not happened in case of ware of Mahabharata where Lord Krishna advised, irritate and aggravate, insist Arjuna to thrown his weapons to killed Karna, when chariot of Karna was failed in the mud, and he was not in chariot and became perplexity and aghast and was trying to remove the wheel of chariot from the muddy soil. At that time Arjuna with the advice of Lord Krishna thrown his arms and weapons to killed Karna and Karna lost his life.
In our shastra it is advice to all of us that not to kill who are not participate in the war, which is in sorrow. Lord Krishna irritates Arjuna to killed Mahatma Vishma who left his arms in the battlefield. Not only that he was also adviced to killed Dronacharya, who was in sorrow hearing the news that his son Aswathama died in the battle field as decleared by Judhistir, that ‘Aswathama Hata Iti Gaja’ with the advice of Lord Krishna. Therefore, from our civic and commonsense we can never say that Lord Krishna follows the rules of humanism. And we put Lord Krishna in the group of inhuman persons. Now question arise why Lord Krishna did such? If we go through the horoscope we will observed that Rahu who is the most non-religious planet present in the 5th house aspect the 9th houses, the house of dharma (religion). Mars the 7th and 12th Lord present in the 9th house and aspect by 8th Lord Jupiter. In case of Vrisha (Taurus) langna Mars is the malefic planet and marak, and Mars is a warrior planet. Again, Jupiter as a malefic and marak planet aspect the 9th house is not good. Therefore, native participated in the war for dharma and himself not been a humanist . The 9th Lord who is the responsible for dharma is in exaltation is good but in 6th house is also bad. 6th house is the house of enemy injury and aspect by malefic, ill-boding, non-religious Rahu through it’s 12th aspect. The cruel nature of the native was developed due to the aspect of malefic Rahu upon ascendant and on mind karka planet Moon, who is also in the Lagna. Rahu is also aspect on the Lagna Lord, and the 9th and 10th lord (Karmapati) Saturn. Again, Rahu is also with intellect karka planet Merecuty, Mercury the 5th lord responsible for intuition (future vision). Again, Rahu aspect on Mars the worrier planet. Sun is aspect by cruel planet Mars. The presence of Saturn in the 6th house insist native to be cruel (in nature), diplomat and adapt in affectedness.
So, how such a person become a humanist whose 9th lord is affected by malefic planet Rahu and and 9th house is expected by the 8th in lord and 12th lord? Therefore, although Krishna now a day may be respected and popular, but he was never be a humanist because he was cruel in nature and violated all norms of humanism during the time of war of Mahabharata.
CASE NO. 02
In our dharma shastra it is advice us not to throw your arms and weapons to killed other who is in the battlefield not with you but with others.
In the Treta Yuga, Lord Ramchandra who was the 3rd person in the war between the Bali and his younger brother Sugriv , throw his arms to killed Bali which is not only the violation of the rules of war but also against the dharmashastra and humanism. So it indicates the inhumanity of Lord Ramchandra. What Ramchandra did was only for his wife Sita who was under Ravana at Lanka during that time. This type of work proves not only the selfishness of Ramchandra but also express the inhumanity of him.
If we go through the horoscope of Lord Ram, it can seen that although the horoscope is no doubt a good horoscope, yet, there is some lacuna which can never be deny. The lagna and lagna lord is affected by malefic planet 8th lord Saturn. The 7th aspect of Mars on lagna and lagna lord irritate the native and loss of religious mind and attitude, and native mind become war crime. The presence of Ketu, which is malefic planet present in the 9th house, is not good for a humanist, and native actually become irreligious minded of humanism. Astrologically actually native became an irreverent person in the eye of humanist. The aspect of Rahu in the 4th house (the house of social work the works for others) is not good. The aspect of Rahu upon 4th lord or Ketu with Venus is not good that when Venus which is also a representative of dharma along with poisonous planet Ketu hamper the religions character of the native and native became a irreverent person. The aspect of Saturn upon 9th lord Jupiter changes the character as irreligious. So, inhumanity found in the birth chart or Ramchandra.Again, he (Ram) also left his wife Sita and his younger brother Lakshmana those who accompany him with their sacrifice at his adverse time. Because his 3rd, 4th and 7th house represents the younger brother, 4th represents happiness and 7th represents wife. Jataka was unable to overcome the effect of such malefic planets.
“The spritual Astrology teaches us that the saints and the seers, the wise and the mystic can rule their stars, the ordinary people obey them” (astrology – X Royed, P-50). Jataka (Lord Ram) was unable to rule his stars, so we can’t say him as an extra ordinary person. He unable to overcome his ‘Dhira Karma’ and he became an inhuman in nature for some times. The great poet William Shakespear what he has written is absolutely true.
“ It is the stars the stars above us
Govern our conditions”.
CASE NO.- 03.
In the shastra it is advice to all that not to kill the person who is not in war, who is only seeing the war, people those who are not participate in the war, innocent people, person who is in fears, whose arms has broken, who is in bare condition, who is sleeping or taking rest. The so-called world leaders did not follow these norms in the present war particularly during the time of 2nd World War. And one of them was Hitler the number one inhuman person.
In the horoscope of Hitler the 9th Lord Mercury is present in the 7th house along with 8th lord Venus, maraca Mars (malefic planet of this lagna Tula), Sun, and aspect by malefic planet Jupiter. The karmapati Moon present in the 3rd house the house of braveness along with the malefic planet Jupiter, the 3rd lord (the braveness) and 6th lord (the enemy, hostility karaka planet) and poisonous planet Ketu. The ascendant is aspect by malefic planet. Sun, Mars, Rahu. Not only that Rahu who is most inhuman karaka planet and responsible for inhuman character of any person and ungodly planet among the all planets present in the house of 9th position, the house of dharma, guru, charity, intuition. Therefore, native never be a religious minded person and also never be a humanist. Actually native killed so many innocent people during the time of 2nd World War and he was the most inhuman person in the world. Jupiter along with Ketu and Rahu in 9th house and retrograde of lagna lord along with warrior planets Mars, Sun and aspect of Saturn upon it leads to jataka as a generalissimo, villain, depravity and corrupt, detestable, vile in nature.
CASE NO. –04
The following horoscope is the renound world famous generalissimo who was the villain in the Ist World War – Mussolini. In this horoscope the 9th lord Moon is in 7th house exaltation along with the cruel planet Mars and malefic retrograde planet Saturn. 5th lord Jupiter is in the 8th house aspect by malefic Rahu. 9th house is aspect by Saturn (with its 3rd aspect). Ascendant is aspect by malefic Rahu and cruel planet Mars, which given anger and cruelty to the native. The aspect of Rahu upon Jupiter given power to do herm against the people, Again 12th and 8th lords Venus and Mercury in 9th house along with 10th lord Karmapati Sun, and the aspect of Saturn upon them give adverse results about the work of religious matter. The ‘Kalsharpa Yoga’ is also observed in this horoscope. The 4th house, which is the house of social works, is also aspect by Rahu. Social work is one kind of religious work. Therefore, native never be religious minded, not only that his arrogance, cruelty and non-religious nature insist him to do harms against the Human Beings and he was become the most inhuman person.
‘Love is the religion of hero and violence is the religion of terrorist, coward, villain. The main recognition of the man is that he is a creator’. But neither the Hitler nor the Mussolini was never be a creator but they are destructor, and inhuman in nature. And for that they were violated all human rights and abuse their power to profane humankind and for that they killed many people and through their violence and the whole world became restless.
In this connection the last discussion between the great humanists Nobel awarded Rabindranath Tagore and Mussolini at Rome on evening dtd. 13.6.1926 before left Rome by Tagore is relevant. Tagore’s views, “Material, wealth and power cannot make a country immortal, she must contribute something which is great and which is for every body, and which does not merely glorify her own self”. Mussolini did not replied and keeps silent because it was known to him that ‘Idealists and humanists are always think and express such.’ He was neither idealist not the humanist, so the advice and sermon from Tagore was meaningless to him. Tagore express his view in they way “Man is his fullness is not powerful but perfect.” Perhaps it was known to him (Tagore) that Mussolini will not accept and followed his suggestions. Yet, he performed his duty because he believed in the ideology that ‘If the people be hard of hearing, yet, hymn of truth must be utter and narrate’.
People says ‘Nah Papey Patipapo Sath’- You should never commit sin or took revenge against him who is against you, in moral or religious offence to do harm’. But it can never be say that it is an advice of a mad and this is called humanism. The implement of such theory in the life is very difficult and depends upon the nature of the person, which can be measured from his horoscope.
Person followed and implemented this theory in his personal life is obviously and humanist. Such persons are Lord Goutam Buddha, Jesus Christ, Cahitanya, Ramkrishna, Rabindranath Tagore and others. The horoscopes of them are as follows:
From the above discussion it can be concluded that the following points are the essential factors found in the horoscope of a humanist or in humanist.
1) A person must be inhuman if Rahu is in the 9th house, because 9th house is the house of dharma or religion. A non-religious person is always inhuman in nature and Rahu is not regious planet.
2) For humanist lagna lord must be good aspect with 9th lord.
3) Presence of Moon must be either in lagna or in the 7th house or it must be good aspect with lagna.
4) 5th lord must either aspect lagna or Moon or lagna lord.
5) Lagna lord may be in exaltation.
6) Jupiter must be either aspect lagna or Moon or lagna lord.
7) No malefic planet either present or aspect 9th and 5th house. (Exception in special case may be found with proper reason) i.e. Ketu is not a malefic planet when present in 9th house.
8) The Raj yoga karaka planet must be in exalteted in the horoscope.
9) Lagna lord, 5th lord, 9th lord may be exaltated.
10) The native must be non-religious and inhuman in nature if any debilitation planet present in the 9th house or the 9th lord is either in the 6th, 8th or 12th house. The nature of native must be miser, selfish, non-religious and inhuman.
11) If the 9th lord be weak and any debilitation planet is in the 9th house and any malefic planet is in lagna and in the 5th house or is in the7th house. If Jupiter may be aspect with Rahu or in the same house the native may be inhuman in nature and he/she do any evil work and must be cruel in nature and never be kind hearted.
The humanism of a great man is no doubt a debatable matter. We have discussed it from our present situation and from our own outlook. Actually socio-economic conditions, situation and history during that time (Huga) when the native was passing his/her lifetime are now not clear to us. Again, the ‘Bargabal’ of the planets, ‘Sayanadi Dadas Bhaba or all planets and ‘Dasa-Antardasha’ of the native are also an important to came to any conclusion and decision. So, the humanity of such great persons is obviously a debatable subject.
A person started to make ready a new passage or narrow lane for walking. Then there is enough persons seen who try to develop the lane to road and converted to street. And there is no deficient of man for waling on the road. Only I have tried to express my approach to the thinkers and request all to developed this new topic from the view point of Jyotish Shastra. Hope, my humble approach will appreciated by the thinkers of this subject.
HOROSCOPE
Lord Krishna ( Case No - 01) : Vrisa- Lagna & Chandra; Karkata- Jupiter; Simha- Ravi; Kanya- Bubha & Rahu; Tula- Sukra & Sani; Makara-Mangala; Mina- Ketu.
Lord Ramchandra ( Case No – 02) : Karkata- Lagna, Chandra & Guru; Kanya- Rahu; Tula- Sani; Makar- Mangal; Mina – Sukra, Rabi & Ketu; Mesh- Budha,
Hitler (Case No - 03) : Tula – Lagna; Dhanu - Guru,Chandra & Ketu: Mesa-Rabi, Budha,Mangal & Sukra (R); Mithun-Rahu; Karkat- Sani
Musolini (Case No - 04) ; Vriscika-Lagna; Mesa-Ketu; Vrisa- Sani, Mangal &Chandra; Mithun- Guru;; Karkat- Rabi, Budh & Sukra; Tula- Rahu.
Lord Goutam Buddha : Karkat- Lagna; Tula-Chandra; Vriscik-Ketu; Mesa- Ravi, Mangal, Guru, Sukra & Sani; Vrisa- Budh; Mithun-Rahu.
Mahaprabhu Cahitanya : Simha- Lagna, Moon & Ketu; Vriscika-Sani; Dhanus- Guru; Makar- Mangal; Kumbha- Ravi & Rahu; Mina- Budha; Mesa- Sukra.
Ramkrishna Paramhansha : Kumbha- Lagna, Moon, Ravi & Budh; Min-Sukra; Vrisa-Ketu; Mithun- Guru; Tula- Sani; Vriscik-Rahu; Makar-Mangal.
Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore : Mina- Lagna[2/31 (25)] & Moon [20/42 (27)]; Mesa- Ravi [ 24/28 (2)], Budh[7/55(1) ] & Sukra [23/13(2)]; Mithun- Mangal [0/10 (5)] & Ketu [24/50 (7)]; Karkata- Guru [25/49 (9)]; Simha- Sani(BAKRI) [10/46 (10)]; Dhanus-Rahu [24/50 (20)]
Jesus Christ : Kanya- Lagna; Vrischik-Rahu & Sukra; Dhanus-Rabi & Budh; Kumbha- Mangal; Mina- Sani, Guru & Chandra; Vrisa- Ketu.
No comments:
Post a Comment